Friday, 8 August 2014

Fifth edition thoughts - the depriving background?

A quick comment on a piece of fifth edition D&D.

At first I was generally positive about the idea of the so-called 'background' - the personality traits, ideals, bonds and flaws. Now I'm not so sure. It seems more gimmicky as time goes by, more predetermining of narrative as if establishing the characters for the first chapter of a novel, a set narrative, rather than supporting an exploration of another world - and ourselves - wherever it leads; and a shortcut avoiding the need for fuller player engagement, or further restricting player freedom.

Why play to someone else's prewritten background if you can decide one for yourself or start vague, as light as in a DCC funnel, or with a single word or less, and let specifics emerge in play, based on choice and the elaboration of the world in the interaction between players and GM, and characters, factions and landscapes? I'm genuinely curious as to the justification. Surely not just to save more of that increasingly precious time..? If so, I've got a suggestion - do less. None of us have to do everything we're sold.

Linked with this is the question of why so many if not all imagined worlds would run off the same few conceptions, let alone a set of supposed real-world or pseudo-mediaeval ideas typical of what could be considered generic, or 'vanilla', even hackneyed in 2014.

Running deeper than that though, I think the background here may be a counteraction of one essential aspect of D&D since the very beginning in the mid-1970s. Let's remember it for a moment - an era pre-cellphone and even pre-PC, of fewer technological crutches - a time when kids roamed relatively fearless and free, in a world of sweat, grease and cassette tape, and adults had a truer time out, un-networked and unpixellated; a world of hallucinogenic vision, free love, free thinking and freedom fighter: an age of analogue, that is, the continuous real. Of pen and paper, and people with their actual physical bodies in all their perfect imperfection engaging with each other around a table, working between and among the relatively few rules as much as with them: being there, giving it everything and feeling the imagined world maybe closer than foreground - in their beings.

The background, because it's not numbers on a scale, but words, seems analogue. But as a frame or a cell for the character to slot into, a point on a scale itself, it's actually digital. It obscures fuller space and its broader potential. We do have digital measures like ability scores, but these don't generally limit the imagining - they provide a means of testing its suitability for a set of assumed physical laws, underlying constraints. A background bounds the imagining even beyond this, pre-empting the idea or guiding it into a more conducive pigeonhole as a presumed prerequisite. It papers over the cracks as if the cracks are not meant to be there, rather than glorying in them as a feature of nature and encouraging us to fall through, go beyond, like Alice. This doesn't seem true to the history of the game, or more importantly its essence, the potential of living beings.

Maybe not so quick, but that's the argument, devil's advocacy or not. It may be others can follow it further and deeper. I think we're open-minded enough to at least consider it.
_

34 comments:

smiler said...

Shit Porky, I didn't know how much I missed you til you came back.

Dennis Laffey said...

I agree that the presented ideals, bonds, flaws, etc. are limited. But I also see them as a) optional and b) customizable.

New players can use them as written. My friends, when we played, used or modified them to suit their concepts, or came up with their own whole cloth.

And the backgrounds' flavor and proficiencies can be used and the other stuff ignored if people don't like it or it doesn't suit their campaigns. Or they can make up their own to suit their campaigns, like Courtney at Hack & Slash is doing. http://hackslashmaster.blogspot.kr/

Unknown said...

I suspect in the future most Backgrounds will be world-centric, whereas these are more generic. Imagine the Backgrounds for something like Dark Sun or an Arabian setting.

Also, I think Backgrounds were a nod to the more modern indie rpgs where character play is more important. In those games players like to have clearly defined backgrounds and things to play off of.

Older D&D was basically "create characters on the fly during play" at least as far as "who" they were. Some modern gamers want predefined things to play off of as it feels more real to them. Personally I always thought the "yes, I was a professional rock-climber in my youth" 2 years into a campaign was all a bit arbitrary.

However, Backgrounds can be used or not used as desired. I suspect the players that need/want that level of development before play starts will use it, but those who prefer to develop on-the-fly won't use it.

Porky said...

@ smiler - However long it lasts this time, wherever we go it'll be the same moon shining down on us both.

@ Lord Gwydion - I agree too, in part. It's optional of course, but customising within the concept won't change its nature, that digital structure. I think the approach could be looser-reined than it is, giving more slack by being finer-grained, less regular, to help the newer player better sense the scope beyond. Of course, there has to be a certain thickness of grain and a certain amount of regularity or it might not seem to be a new product, or be a product easy to get into. It also has to reflect expectations generated by the direction fourth edition took, and beyond that third.

@ Callin - I think you're right about the influences and the likely direction. The development of background in play could be expected to be well-integrated, in that presumably any given group expects emergence from the shared context - less 'I was a professional rock climber in my youth' than 'we used to scale the sea cliffs for shale bee honey'. As with so much, it comes down to the communication between the players.

Porky said...

This set for early D&D takes a more freeing approach, essentially being a single word for inspiration plus the related ability and some quick-start core equipment (and companions in the case of the animals). But in a more rules-light system - like OD&D for a start - even this is unnecessary, although a sample could work well as examples of more familiar concepts to show a new player. Any player can go freer still just by choosing anything at all that fits the shared understanding - and helps shape it - then agreeing a similar scope of ability in a quick exchange with the other players and GM, either at the outset or as related situations arose - it's easy enough to take presumed ability into account in any given ruling or roll.

Jens D. said...

I believe D&D is Gygax's feverish vision of the digital age, interpreted with analogue tools by what you might call an "analogue native" ... That's why the games translate so well into the digital. Extensive use of tables and charts could be argued as other indicators that this is the truth and nothing else. But the way you present it, it's well worth some more reflection.

Other than that, I agree with you. It's not only unnecessary, but problematic even for all the reasons you give (and maybe more?).

What's wrong with the good old "Character-development is what happens on the first 6 levels ..."? Every now and then I get the impression that rules like this support the illusion that players are consumers, not creators. And that's poison for the game.

Porky said...

That's worth reflecting on. It makes me wonder to what extent D&D could have been - or become - a flight from the rigour of wargaming and the need to model the real world, and to a lesser or greater degree despite the core creators. Gygax worked in insurance of course. Linked with that, Dave Arneson is quoted here (and thanks to Semper Initiativus Unum for the link) as saying:

"We would get in these arguments, though, about historical accuracy, the latest translation of the latest book, and what was "real." Going into a fantasy world was actually again kind of a copout from my point of view. I didn't want people always coming up with some new book saying we just had to use because it was right and the old one was wrong."

marcellus said...

I am thankful for the article post.Looking forward to visit more.

www.office.com/setup

SHOPnROAR said...

Good health and good sense are two of life's greatest blessings.
Online Shopping Engine
Best Price Online Shopping
Price Comparison
Best Price Online Shopping Engine
Price Comparison Engine
Price Compare for Online Shopping
Best Price Search Engine
comparison shopping engine
compare store prices
best price comparison site
Comparison Shopping Search Engine
Comparative Engine

jolly said...

awesome site.
mcafee.com/activate

www.office.com/setup

officecomcomoffice said...

office.com/setup - For Downloading, Installing and activating the Office product key, visit www.office.com/setup and Get Started by now Office setup. http://officecomcomoffice.com/

Office-ComOffice-Com - www-office.com/setup said...

office.com/setup, Office Setup with product key Visit www.office.com/setup and follow the on-screen instructions for Office 2019, Office 365, Step by Step.

Office-ComOffice-Com - www-office.com/setup said...

After visiting office.com/setup login to microsoft account to buy contract of office setup, Any misery in www.office.com/setup our sting will assert going on for office install.

Office-ComOffice-Com - www-office.com/setup said...

office.com/setup - For Downloading, Installing and activating the Office product key, visit www.office.com/setup and Get Started previously Office setup.

Bola Pelangi said...

Come to my website to view the contents of my website
BOLA PELANGI - BANDAR MIX PARLAY TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME.
Join US ! klik link di bawah ini ☟

Prediksi Parlay Jitu
Mix Parlay
Bola Jalan
U build Great Artikel ^_^ i already Share this artikel
Bandar Bola

Bola Online
Berita Bola
Prediksi Parlay

Untuk Info Dan Bonus Menariknya Bisa Hubungi Kami Di Bawah Ini :
WHATSAPP 1 : +6282143134681
WHATSAPP 2 : +6281333472723

Ayo buruann , mana tau kamu menjadi jutawan setelah bergabung dengan kami .. buruann !!!

♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay = https://www.facebook.com/groups/346501502486292/
♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_01/Bola Pelangi
♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/bolapelangilounge/ Bolapelangi Lounge
✆ WA = +6282143134681 || +6281333472723a

technation said...

For Downloading, Installing and activating the Office product, visit office.com/setup and Get Started with Office.

If you want guided-solutions on how to download, install, and activate norton.com/setup and norton.com/nu16 that will help secure your device from threats.

Add another email account to the Gmail app · Change your Gmail settings · Change email notifications visit : email support

Bittrex is a global leader in the blockchain revolution. We operate the premier U.S.-based blockchain trading platform, which is designed for customers who demand lightning-fast trade execution, dependable digital wallets, and industry-leading security practices.

bittrex support

smith warner said...

Norton.com/setup - Navigate to the www.norton.com/setup in case you want to go through the easy guidelines for downloading, installing, and activating your Norton setup successfully.

Unknown said...

Online Purchase:– To get it on the web, one can visit the Norton Website and can buy any of the Norton Setup thing. For that, you can visit Norton.com/Setup. Customers gets their thing key by systems for email.

Pussy Hunter said...

Judi Online

Jhonny Cikolapek said...

Come to my website to view the contents of my website
BOLA PELANGI2 - SITUS MAIN GAME ONLINE TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME. Join US ! klik link di bawah ini ☟
Prediksi Jitu Bola
Bola Online
Main Game online


Untuk Info Dan Bonus Menariknya Bisa Hubungi Kami Di Bawah Ini :
WHATSAPP 1 : +85570758205

Ayo buruann , mana tau kamu menjadi jutawan setelah bergabung dengan kami ..
♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay Dan Bola Jalan = https://https://www.facebook.com/groups/176360512919094/
♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_02
♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/prediksijituparlayy/

IDN POKER 88 ONLINE TERPERCAYA said...

PREDIKSI TOGEL HONGKONG 15 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI TOGEL SYDNEY 15 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI TOGEL SINGAPORE 15 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI TOGEL HK
PREDIKSI TOGEL SYDNEY
PREDIKSI TOGEL SG
PREDIKSI BOLA LEVANTE VS SEVILLA 16 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI BOLA REAL BETIS VS GRANADA 16 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI BOLA REAL BETIS VS GRANADA 16 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI BOLA REAL BETIS VS GRANADA 16 JUNI 2020
PREDIKSI BOLA LEVANTE VS SEVILLA 16 JUNI 2020

rokupcexpert said...

Get the best & affordable Microsoft www.office.com/setup support for your business with best package. Reach out us & enjoy our fastest & satisfactory services.

Unknown said...

mcafee.com/activate: Get security from online-threats like viruses with McAfee antivirus. Download, install, and activate it on www.mcafee.com/activate.

unknown said...


As we are aware of the fact already that commercial inspection is very different from residential inspection hence the expertise needed for this to be done are different as well. Commercial inspector is someone who has the necessary experience needed for a commercial inspection which needs certifications and education required by the state along with a portfolio that states that they have done it before and the customers were happy and satisfied with the outcome of the inspection. As neglected as this perspective can be because there is more work when you are just a home inspector, being a commercial building inspector can be pretty rewarding as well because commercial buildings obviously cover more area hence the money will be good and as commercial building inspections are covered by companies, everything will be done more professionally along with the less hassle of having to involve in negotiations. All in all, commercial inspection can be pretty rewarding if a real estate inspector gets a good grip over it.

unknown said...

While there are a ton of residential inspectors present around us always luring us to get a home inspection done from them and many home inspection companies are offering numerous perks if we get a home inspection done from them, when it comes to a commercial inspection, the list narrows down to a limited number and the reason behind this is that commercial property inspection is something on a bigger level and it requires a lot of expertise in order to get it right. When we search with words like commercial property inspection near me while residing in Atlanta, we may get a handsome amount of commercial inspectors on the search results but we should know what to look for before taking any decision. Champia Real Estate Inspections is a company offering expert services for people who are looking for a skilled and experienced commercial real estate inspector to help them in their time of need. They have been working since 1987 and have a number of positive reviews which is a guarantee itself that you will not be disappointed when to get their services.



unknown said...

Commercial property inspection is a term which is used when the help of a real estate inspector is needed on a bigger level. It is not just about a house anymore. In order to get done with this process, experience and skill is needed because we are never sure what will be in the box for us because in a place like Atlanta, commercial properties can be of any size and it is not possible for a regular home inspector to bluff on this level that he can satisfy the clients completely. Commercial property inspectors are experts who know exactly what they are dealing with. They are aware that anything can be present on the commercial property and it can be of any size so they need to be prepared prior to the inspection day and they should know how they are going to satisfy the client who is looking for their help regarding their commercial property.

Herman Herrington said...

There are numerous approaches to watch Netflix on your TV – all you require is a gadget with the Netflix application! The Netflix application is accessible on many Smart TVs, game consoles, streaming media players, set-top boxes, and Blu-beam players. You can discover more data about viable gadgets and brands at www.netflix.com/activate, and to enroll visit www.netflix.com/activate or read on to check whether your TV is now Netflix-prepared.

Netflix Activation
www.netflix.com/redeem
netflix activation code
netflix.com.au/redeem
netflix.com/tv8

nick jones said...

all paypal login errors solutions here
paypal login |
paypal log in |

Shoaib Amin said...

This is my lucky chance to call from a friend because he sees important information being shared on your site.
It is a good idea to read through your blog posts.
Thank you so much for thinking so much of readers like me and I wish you the best of success as a professional.
window product key
outbyte pc repair crack
icecream screen recorder crack
avast premier crack license key

Henry Stevens said...

Howdy! This article could not have been written any better!
Reading this post makes me think of my old roommate!
He was continuously talking about it. This page will be forwarded to him.
I'm confident he'll enjoy the read. Thank you for sharing your knowledge!

itools crack
malware hunter crack
unity pro crack
bandicam screen recorder crack

decodersdigital said...

A really nice blog where we can found useful information.Thanks you.
The best digital marketing company in the world for web development.
decoders digital marketing company
best digital marketing company

daysiedarla said...

We are not Amazon. This website is for information purposes only. For more help, visit
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv enter code
amazon.ca/redeem
primevideo/mytv

daysiedarla said...

It is important to remember that Amazon Prime Video is not compatible with every streaming device. Perhaps this is due to the fact that Amazon Prime Video is still relatively new. The service is still available on many devices.
www.primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv

daysiedarla said...

We all noticed a dramatic shift in viewer preferences with the rise in OTT platforms. Movies have stopped going to the theaters due to the pandemic. They simply made it possible to access the OTT platforms from anywhere in the world. You can register, verify, and activate the MyTV app via www.amazon.com/mytv to become one of the most well-known web show distributors.
primevideo/mytv
primevideo/mytv
www.amazon.com/mytv enter code
amazon.com/redeem